It is going to be quite the entertaining slate of football. As with any new league, there are many unknowns. Sure, we can analyze all we want – but, until we see the product each team actually puts on the field, pre-season predictions can only go so far.
With that in mind, it’s time to make some predictions. Let’s take a look at who’s likely in line to start for each XFL team – and, which quarterbacks should make the biggest impact this weekend.
It would make sense to see Kyle Sloter play a major role in Arlington’s offense, at least to start. Sloter is, by far, the most accomplished quarterback on the Renegades roster. He has had plenty of success with multiple NFL organizations, and most recently spent pre-season with the Jacksonville Jaguars.
Sloter played in the USFL in 2022. He helped lead the New Orleans Breakers to the playoffs, serving as an All-USFL QB for the team.
For those of you might be unfamiliar with Kyle Sloter (playing in the HOF game), he was one of the USFL's premier quarterbacks; when healthy. It's great to see him back on an NFL field.
If Bob Stoops takes the same approach that he did in 2020, expect Sloter to start. Stoops stuck with Landry Jones for most of the 2020 season – at least, when Jones was healthy – due to Jones’ previous accolades as a quarterback.
In addition, Sloter is already familiar with some of Arlington’s pieces (i.e. Sal Cannella). If Sloter can settle into a comfortable role in Stoops’ system, the Renegades will have one of the most potent offenses in the XFL.
Jordan Ta’amu brings quite a bit of talent to DC’s starting lineup. Reggie Barlow has a very versatile QB in Ta’amu, as he can impact the game through the air – and on the ground.
In 2022, Ta’amu led the USFL in passing yards, and touchdowns for the Tampa Bay Bandits. Unfortunately, the team didn’t make the postseason; but, Ta’amu performed quite well considering how inconsistent the pieces were around him.
Silvers has been around in plenty of spring leagues himself (AAF, TSL, XFL). He has the starting experience that most other 2023 quarterbacks don’t have in spring football. For all intents and purposes, Silvers would be the “safe” choice for Houston.
In contrast, Cole McDonald could prove to be the guy that the Roughnecks need to stay undefeated. McDonald was sensational in college at Hawaii. Like almost every other XFL quarterback, though, he hasn’t proved himself at a professional level.
While McDonald isn’t exactly a dual threat QB, he is surprisingly quick for his size. He ran for over 700 yards in his final two seasons at Hawaii, on top of throwing for almost 8,000 yards and 70 touchdowns. Given the potential that McDonald possesses, it would be wise to let him start the season as the signal caller.
The situation in Orlando is pretty unique. Deondre Francois was originally assigned to the team back in November. However, since then the former first round NFL pick – Paxton Lynch – signed with the Guardians.
It will be interesting to see how everything plays out. First and foremost, Lynch certainly possesses quite a bit of talent. We saw him display his leadership down the stretch in the USFL, leading the Michigan Panthers to a big-time win to finish the season.
The @PaxtonLynch Game: 275 yards, 3 TD | Week 10 vs. Pittsburgh
With that in mind, Francois is an intriguing prospect simply because we don’t know what he is fully capable of. Francois has been excellent in the FCF over the past couple of years. He is also a dual threat QB, bringing an additional set of skills to the team.
Fans were able to pick team names, submit & choose logos, draft players, call plays and so on.
The San Antonio Brahmas announced that Jack Coan will be their starting QB in week one. Coan is certainly one of the sleepers in the XFL. He doesn’t get the “hype” that others (i.e. McCarron, Hundley) may get.
That being said, Jack Coan is a solid choice for Hines Ward in San Antonio. Coan had an excellent college career at Wisconsin, before transferring to Notre Dame for his final year.
Jack Coan popped his finger back in and then threw the game winning TD
Ben is looking to find his footing on a professional stage. He spent a few years with the Dallas Cowboys, seeing some production here and there. Now, he turns to the XFL for the next chapter of his career.
DiNucci put up excellent numbers at James Madison. In just two years he threw for 5,700 yards and 45 touchdowns. In addition, he did play reasonably well during his limited minutes in Dallas throughout both the pre-season and the regular season.
Anthony Becht wanted AJ McCarron on his team. Now, with only a few days left in training camp, it appears as if McCarron will be the starter.
This fit feels natural for the team. Given that the Battlehawks released QB Ryan Willis, McCarron has emerged as the likely signal caller for St. Louis. Nick Tiano will be next in line, and the team did just sign Manny Wilkins. However, given McCarron’s current status on the team, we should expect to see him get minutes before anyone else.
— #1 TEAM IN THE COUNTRY BARSTOOL BAMA (@BarstoolAlabama) July 8, 2022
McCarron has had quite the journey to the XFL. The former standout at Alabama saw some success in the NFL, with the Cincinnati Bengals. After that, he was bounced around between a couple of other NFL organizations, but couldn’t find stability.
Clearly, Becht wanted AJ in St. Louis. He played a major role in getting him into the XFL. With kickoff just around the corner, those St. Louis faithful will likely be cheering for McCarron as they watch the Battlehawks return to their city.
Rod Woodson has a very unique situation in Vegas. The team abruptly released Bryan Scott mid-way through training camp, signing NFL veteran Brett Hundley.
You would think that a move like this means that Hundley is the starter. However, that isn’t guaranteed just yet, especially when you consider the other potential starting QB on the roster.
Luis Perez is a spring football journeyman. He’s played in almost every spring league known to man. Perez is the ultimate game manager. He just came off a spectacular USFL season, completing 71% of his touchdowns. He also threw nine touchdowns, to just one interception.
Luis Perez is coming off of his best spring football season yet. The journeyman led the @USFLGenerals to a 9-1 record, dominating the #USFL. He completed 72% of his passes in 2022, throwing 9 TD's to just 1 INT.
The thing that makes this scenario so interesting is the unknown potential that Hundley brings to Vegas. Woodson knows what he’s going to get with Perez.
Meanwhile, Hundley has been in the NFL for years – but hasn’t touched spring football yet. At the same time, it would be odd for the team to pursue the NFL vet if they didn’t intend on him playing a role in the offense in 2023.
While it’s still currently a toss up, it would make sense to see Hundley get the start. If the Brett “experiment” doesn’t go according to plan, Woodson can let Perez take the reins. Given Hundley’s NFL status (and his paycheck), the Vipers should probably start him in week one.
At the end of the day, we’ll just have to wait for game day. Not every team has announced their starting quarterbacks quite yet. However, the XFL’s kickoff is just days away…so these reveals should be on their way soon.