Matt Coghlin Deserves A True NFL Opportunity. Here’s Why.

Matt Coghlin Deserves A True NFL Opportunity. Here’s Why.

Time and time again, we have seen UFL specialists go to the NFL and exceed all expectations. The storylines continue to pile up year after year. Brandon Aubrey, Jake Bates, KaVontae Turpin – and now Lucas Havrisik – the list goes on.

Consistent Special Teams play is one of the most important facets to any pro football organization. If we’re being honest, there’s multiple clubs in the NFL who haven’t had that consistency over the years. There’s a reason why spring football specialists have been given opportunities – NFL teams are looking to every avenue possible to bring in reliable, trustworthy special teams players.

With that in mind: why hasn’t kicker Matt Coghlin received an NFL offer yet?

It’s a tough question to answer, and one that is rather baffling. Matt Coghlin has spent the last three years in the USFL and UFL – and he’s been elite every single year.

Coghlin played his college football at Michigan State. He set a school record for most points scored (382), alongside most field goals made (76).

While Matt didn’t immediately receive an NFL look, he continued to train – and landed in the USFL for the 2023 season. He kicked for the New Orleans Breakers, knocking through 18 of 19 field goal attempts, with a long of 55 yards. Coghlin also was 25-25 on XP’s.

With the Breakers folding in the USFL-XFL merger, Coghlin made his way to the UFL with the Memphis Showboats. His strong play has continued over the last two seasons, making 32 of 36 kicks with a long of 57 yards.

Unfortunately, the UFL doesn’t include XP’s for kickers, so he doesn’t have experience on that end the last two years. With that said, Coghlin never missed an XP in college, or the USFL. So that’s certainly not a concern.

There’s no denying that he’s got the leg strength to make an NFL roster. Three of his four misses in the UFL came from 50+ yards out, and even then, he’s made eight 50+ yarders across his spring career. His lone miss from 40 yards away wasn’t even his fault – it was a blocked kick due to a whiffed block. Matt hasn’t missed a kick from <50 yards since week six of the 2023 USFL season.

His experience on kickoffs is another factor that comes into play. The NFL recently implemented the “XFL-style” kickoff, to improve player safety and increase returns.

Coghlin has been essentially spotless on kickoffs the last two years in the UFL, with just one of his 78 attempts going out of bounds. It’s worth noting that lone kick took place in 2024, when the UFL still featured the more traditional USFL-style kickoff. In 2025, Matt averaged 62.5 yards per kickoff – the perfect sweet spot with the new “landing zone” setup.

We spoke with former Breakers and Showboats Head Coach, John DeFilippo, about his time working with Coghlin. Here’s what he had to say:

“Matt’s accurate, and he takes his job seriously. He’s professional. The guy’s respected in the locker room. He’s a terrific teammate. I can’t say enough great things about him. I’m shocked that he hasn’t gotten a chance to kick in the NFL yet. He’s done more than enough for an opportunity.”

All of that to say: Matt Coghlin has earned an NFL look, plain and simple. All he needs is one chance to prove himself in camp. It’s long overdue, but he’s done everything he needs to do – and more – to receive an opportunity. At 28 years old, he’s got plenty of gas left in the tank as a professional.

What are your thoughts on Matt Coghlin and his career so far? Which NFL team should give him a look? Let us know down in the comments below, or join the conversation on Discord!

XFL, USFL, UFL, CFL Retro Jerseys, Shirts, Hats & more